Can an insurance carrier subrogate against a third party that caused damage to their insured's vehicle if the third party already paid the vehicle owner's damages?

Answer:

No. That would mean the third party tortfeasor would pay twice, which would amount to unjust enrichment.

First answer by Glendaleatty. Last edit by Glendaleatty. Contributor trust: 166 [recommend contributor recommended]. Question popularity: 3 [recommend question].