You can only get it if you had a file in 2005 and then moved on to My Lego Network. If you made an account before or when they switched to My Lego Network, they would give you the badge. Other than...
sorry bud, you would have to be in the 2005 migration of club pages to my Lego network pages. I was bummed out too, my Lego name is: jeddaswedda, but unless you can go back in time to the 2005...