This might depend on
a) what is in the cans
b) how accurate the scales are
If a can with liquid in it is left open overnight some moisture may be lost by evaporation - making it slightly lighter than the unopened can.
If a can is open, some particles of dust might drift into it - more than would settle on an unopened can - and make it slightly heavier than the unopened can.
However, If the can has nuts in it I'll be tempted to take one or two, or a handful - making it considerably lighter than the unopened one.