Was the US Constitution a strong central government at the expense of states' rights?

Answer:

Absolutely.

The framers of the Constitution, including Madison, Hamilton, and Washington, had watched the country deteriorate under the Articles of Confederation. The Articles had left the states fully sovereign, while the central government barely functioned (it could not even raise its own revenue. It depended on contributions from the states, much like the UN). They saw veterans riot over the Confederal Congerss' inability to pay pensions, and they saw Shay's Rebellion nearly cripple the government of Massachusetts.

The states also squabbled over their borders and fought for land in the west. It seemed that without a more unified central government, peace could not be guaranteed.

So, when the framers met in Philadelphia in 1787, they sought to create a government strong enough to enable free trade among the states, quell domestic rebellions, and stand strong on the international stage. To do this, they had to prohibit the states from acting independently. Thus, the new Constitution actually did, and was intended to, take away rights from the individual states, and create "a more perfect union." It was only the Anti-federalists (opposed to its ratification), who were in favor of retaining states' rights. From then on, the central government has grown stronger, and the nation has been more prosperous.

First answer by ID1146353734. Last edit by ID1146353734. Question popularity: 9 [recommend question].

Can you answer these US Constitution questions?

Relevant answers:

Related topics:

Related Ads:

Related ads:

Sign in using:

Answers.com members:



Join using:

Join Answers.com:




Why join?
Joining is free and easy. You can still be anonymous; just choose any username and password.

  • Get notified about updated answers
  • Follow your favorite categories
  • Get credit for your contributions
  • Customize your profile
  • Answer questions more easily
Not convinced? Read more.
Lost your password?

You may already have an Answers.com account.
Click here to connect your accounts.  

If you don't want to connect accounts, you can start a new one from scratch.
Minor details...


  

Connect your accounts...




Lost password?
Why do we need your email address?
We will use your email address to send you updates (if you request them) about questions you ask, answer or track, and to help you retrieve your password if you forget it.

Your email address will not be used for any other purpose without your permission.
Already have an Answers.com account? Connect your accounts!
By doing so, you include all of your history (contributions, messages, profile) from your Answers.com account in your Facebook account.

If you don't connect accounts, your new account will be starting from scratch.