What are the advantages of TTL over CMOS?

Answer

TTL is less sensitive to static-discharge failure and less expensive. It is also faster.

Answer

There is a condition called "latch up" that can happen with CMOS circuits if an overvoltage is applied during operation, so you have to design the input/output buffers to suit the operating conditions, like if a wire is attached.

The first commercial applications of CMOS were by a company called Integrated Device Technology (IDT). Strangely enough, the singular advantage at that time was that CMOS allowed Hewlett Packard to create a practical calculator that was able to retain its memory registers when powered down. (Power was maintained to the chip, but the chip clock was stopped, and the chip could retain its state on very low power.) Before that though, the U.S. Navy used CMOS to reduce the size of circuits jammed in the nose cones of missiles so they could pack them with more explosives instead.

TTL (Transistor-Transistor Logic) uses a different type of transistor (bipolar) whereas CMOS uses MOSFETs (metal oxide semiconductor field effect transistor). FETs don't have current flowing into the "gate" when static, whereas bipolars do (into the "base"), so generally this allows them to operate with lower power especially in a stand-by type of state.

Before CMOS there was NMOS, which used N transistors and resistors. It's a bit complicated to explain in lay terms without a decent diagram, but CMOS stands for "Complimentary MOS" and uses a P transistor in place of the resistor. The advantage here is no static current flow is required, only at switching.

Bipolar or TTL can in fact be faster, although it's not an apples-to-apples comparison because there are different processes for each. Some hybrids have been created like "BiCMOS," where both are combined on one chip.

This is probably a lot more than you wanted to know. In short, CMOS is many things, but with the huge amounts of money invested in CMOS today it obviously has all the advantages necessary to be the default technology for most integrated electronics.

  • Other contributors say:

CMOS logic has advantage of having smaller dimensions with new coming (usually smaller) technologies. Thus, the RC constant (RC defines transition time, where R = resistance is coming from R-ON resistance and C = capacitance is coming from gate capacitance) is smaller. Smaller RC constant means shorter transition (0->1 or 1->0)time. Logic is faster and can do more in same time (provided faster system clock). Same functionality is having smaller silicon area and this also means lower price for same functionality. Therefore the CMOS is very popular today and widely used.

Concerning the ESD, yes CMOS is more sensitive, because breakdown of MOS gate is always destructive while impact of junction breakdown still depends on ESD pulse energy. Nevertheless, low-voltage CMOS is relatively easy to protect and our company has standard of 4kV ESD HBM (human body model) susceptibility as minimum. I do not remember problems after hand manipulation in the lab.

Improve Answer Discuss the question "What are the advantages of TTL over CMOS?" Watch Question

First answer by ID3628787730. Last edit by Bravenec. Contributor trust: 111 [recommend contributor]. Question popularity: 149 [recommend question]

Research your answer:

Answers.com > Wiki Answers > Categories > Technology > Consumer Electronics > What are the advantages of TTL over CMOS?

Our contributors said this page should be displayed for the questions below. (Where do these come from)
If any of these are not a genuine rephrasing of the question, please help out and edit these alternates.
Ttl against cmos?  Comparison TTL and CMOS?  Advantages of TTL families?  What are advantages of TTL?  Which is better DTL or TTL?  Advantages of cmos over ttl?  Why is TTL faster than CMOS?  Why ttl are faster than cmos?  Pros and cons off ttl vs cmos?  Compare ttl cmoshybird version ttl?  Propergation delay between cmos and ttl?  What are the advantages of cmos over ttl?  What are the advantages of CMOS over TTLS?  What is the advantages and disadvantage of CMOS?  What are the values of vohvihvolvil for ttl and cmos?  Compare and contrast the characteristics of cmos and ttl?  What are the advantages of TTL over CMOS in terms of Power consumption?