0
What does 'the switch in time that saved nine' mean in reference to the US Supreme Court in 1937?
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Answer
A "switch in time" (obviously a play on "a stitch in time saves nine") refers to when Justice Roberts did an unexpected change and voted to support one of FDR's new deal pieces of legislation even though he had consistently been against New Deal legislation.
The "saves nine" portion because FDR was threatening a court packing plan to increase the number of justices up to 15 to make sure that the old guard would be outnumbered. (And of course there were and still are nine justices on the Supreme Court)
Answer
"The switch in time that saved nine" refers to US Supreme Court swing voter Justice Owen Roberts' 1937 decision to begin voting with the progressive bloc of justices, ending the Court's blockade of New Deal legislation. This decision is alleged to have been made just in time to prevent Roosevelt from implementing his controversial court-packing scheme. In fact, Congress stripped Roosevelt's provision from the bill and Roberts had apparently decided how he was going to vote on the case prior to Roosevelt announcing his judicial reorganization plan.
Explanation
In April 1937, the Supreme Court's swing voter, Justice Owen Roberts, shifted his vote on New Deal programs from conservative to liberal, giving the Roosevelt administration an important win in West Coast Hotel v. Parrish, (1937), upholding a state minimum wage law. This shift was referred to as "the switch in time that saved nine," meaning Owens' decision to vote with the liberal bloc saved the nine justices from Roosevelt's scheme (the phrase was a play on the old aphorism, "a stitch in time saves nine."). (Historians claim Owens' decision had already been made before the Judiciary Reorganization Bill was announced.) The Court also delivered two unanimous opinions on New Deal-friendly cases the same day. These decisions further decayed voter support for reorganization.
For more information, see Related Questions, below.
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What was the switch in time that saved nine?
The switch in time that saved nine is the term for the seemingly sudden change in the vote of Justice Owen Roberts to side with the conservatives in voting against the court reform bill. It is a play on the phrase "a stitch in time saves nine", because the vote saved the 9 Supreme Court justices from the reform bill that would add more justices.
Are there any Mexican-Americans on the US Supreme Court?
We currently do, yes (assuming you are referring to the United States Supreme Court). Her name is Sonia Sotomayor, and she was nominated by President Barack Obama; she has served on the Court since August 2009. She had previously served as a judge and lawyer in several other positions, and was best known for filing an injunction that ended the 1995 Major League Baseball Strike -- earning her praise from some for having "saved baseball."Whether she is the first Hispanic justice actually sparked a brief discussion around the time of her nomination. A prior justice, Benjamin Cardozo, had been born to a family of Sephardic Jews originally from Portugal. The consensus, soon agreed upon, was that the term "Hispanic" must refer to someone whose heritage is in either Spain or Spanish-speaking Latin America. Under that definition, Brazilians would not be Hispanic, and neither would Cardozo. Thus, Sotomayor is the first.
What events saved Jamestown from destruction?
The reformation of tabacco and the new cultures that formed!!
Who saved the Jamestown colony?
John Smith, a harsh and brutal ruler who forced the colonial "gentlemen" to work hard for the good of the colony, is generally said to have saved Jamestown.
The Jamestown settlers saved their colony by planting what?
Tobacco
What was the switch in time that saved nine?
The switch in time that saved nine is the term for the seemingly sudden change in the vote of Justice Owen Roberts to side with the conservatives in voting against the court reform bill. It is a play on the phrase "a stitch in time saves nine", because the vote saved the 9 Supreme Court justices from the reform bill that would add more justices.
When did Roosevelt's court-packing plan become unnecessary?
Roosevelt's court-packing plan became unnecessary when the swing voter on the US Supreme Court, Justice Owen Roberts, shifted his (and the Court's) support to favor the New Deal when he voted minimum wage laws were constitutional in West Coast Hotel v. Parrish, (1937). This is often referred to as "the switch in time that saved nine," although historians suggest Owens' may have made his decision prior to the court-packing scandal.Older members of the Court began dying or retiring in 1937, eventually vacating eight of the nine Supreme Court seats. This allowed President Roosevelt to realize his desire for a liberal court through legitimate appointments.
What are the release dates for Saved from Court Martial - 1912?
Saved from Court Martial - 1912 was released on: USA: 31 August 1912
Importance of written communication?
reference,large audience will be saved
What actors and actresses appeared in Saved by the Juvenile Court - 1913?
The cast of Saved by the Juvenile Court - 1913 includes: Ben Lindsey as himself
What is invasion fever in reference to world war 2?
fat jews were saved
What information about a process needs to saved changed or updated when context switching takes place?
any and all information about the job is saved before the contexted switch anything already completed is also saved.
What are the release dates for Mario Lopez Saved by the Baby - 2010 Courtney's Made the Switch 1-5?
Mario Lopez Saved by the Baby - 2010 Courtney's Made the Switch 1-5 was released on: USA: 29 November 2010
What are the release dates for Saved by the Bell The New Class - 1993 Student Court 4-7?
Saved by the Bell The New Class - 1993 Student Court 4-7 was released on: USA: 28 September 1996
What are the ratings and certificates for Saved by the Bell The New Class - 1993 Student Court 4-7?
Saved by the Bell The New Class - 1993 Student Court 4-7 is rated/received certificates of: USA:TV-G
How is time saved when you switch to Daylight Saving Time?
Time is not saved, daylight is. This means it is the time for saving daylight. What kind of noob asked this question anyways?
Can you keep your saved pictures when you switch carriers?
Yes, you can keep your pictures and usually you can keep the phone.
