Answer:
I have hazely amber eyes, and I've learned the hard way what to put on them. Steer away from greens! They dull the gold of your eyes. Reach instead for champagne and gold on pale skin, or purple for darker complexions. For evening, try a smokey eye. Traditional grays look lovely, but you can also do a golden smokey eye. It looks gorgeous and natural.
Good luck and remember: Amber eyes are beautiful!