English Catholics.
Trinitarian Christians.
The Colony was established as a safe haven and refuge for European Quakers. But it was also a safe haven for any monotheistic religion.
The catholics
If you are talking about on Howrse, The Safe Haven is a place where you can put your horse if you don't want it anymore. It will have a very happy life there, If you go there, you can stroke a horse...
The Catholics held the political power in the Colony but were never the majority religion.