0
What is the flaws of the electoral college concerning the popular vote vs the electoral vote?
Wiki User
∙ 13y ago
A candidate could be elected by having a majority of the Electoral votes, but losing the popular vote. And (at one time) Electors were not bound to vote the same way as the majority in their state had voted.
Wiki User
∙ 13y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
One of the major flaws in the electoral college system is that the winner of the popular vote is not guaranteed the presidency True Or False?
True.
What are the major flaws in the the electoral college system?
none
What are the 3 major flaws in the electoral college system?
none
What flaws are in the national bonus plan?
Some flaws of the national bonus plan are that it's a difficult process for people to understand, and it isn't gathering a lot of interest. Another problem is, it doesn't fully eliminate the current system of the Electoral College.
What are seen as some flaws in the electoral college?
1) In close elections, the winner of the Electoral College may not have won a majority of the popular vote. (However, the only instance in which a candidate who received a majority(50%+1) but lost the election was in 1876; in 1888 and 2000 the winner of the popular vote lost, but no candidate had a majority.)2) Electoral College members are chosen based on party loyalty and almost always vote in accordance with party wishes, not the will of the people. In fact, in some states it is against the law for an Electoral College member to vote against their party; however, these laws are unenforceable.3) If under extreme circumstances the Electoral College is tied or deadlocked or there are unresolvable disputes over the validity of election returns, the House of Representatives chooses the president, using even more eccentric rules than the Electoral College. Each state gets one vote regardless of size, meaning Wyoming's vote would be in equal standing with California's, and conceivably a candidate with only a small fraction of the popular vote could win. However, this hasn't happened since 1824.Of course, this all assumes that a direct popular election is preferable to an indirect election. The Electoral College also carries certain advantages over a popular election, including the fact that under the Electoral College, one candidate nearly always wins a majority of the electoral vote (regardless of their showing in the popular vote) and there is little need for runoff or second-round voting. And also, since the elections are compartmentalized by state, in extremely close contests, there is no need for costly and exhaustive nationwide recounts of 100+ million ballots.
In what year did flaws in the electoral system first begin to appear?
Flaws in the electoral system began to appear in 1796. The system, at that time, resulted in the President and Vice President being from different political parties.
In what year did flaws in the electoral system first seriously threaten the nation?
1879
Have the electoral college already voted?
The electoral college is the method stipulated in Article II, Section I of the constitution for election of the president and vice president. Originally each state chose electors equal in number to the representatives and senators. They voted for 2 candidates each at least one of whom had to be from another state.. The person getting the most votes became president and the runner up vice president. If no one got the majority the House was to choose the president and vice president from the three leading candidates. Modern critics note that it has several dangerous flaws. For example a president can be elected with a majority of electoral votes even though his opponent has won the majority of popular votes. Now, that I have given a history of what this is I can answer your question. The last time the electoral college voted was after the election in 2008. It will vote again when the results of the next election are finished in 20012. Today the man/woman who gets the popular vote in each state the electoral college votes for that state goes to the candidate who got the most votes.
What is the main complaint against the electoral college?
The electoral college's main failing is that it does not accurately represent the popular vote of the nation. Each state is given a certain amount of electoral votes, and then the electoral votes are used to determine the winner of US presidential elections. So if you voted for Candidate A, but Candidate B won the majority in your state, your whole state goes to Candidate B in the electoral college--effectively disempowering your vote.---Because most states award all of their electoral votes to the top vote-getter in that state, candidates do not need to win the national popular vote to win a majority of electoral votes. The result is that winning a few large population states (called swing states), even by a tiny margin, can guarantee election to the presidency. In 1876, 1888, and 2000, the winning candidate did not get the most popular votes nationwide.It is possible, but unlikely, that getting as little as 25% of the total popular vote (the most votes in 11 swing states) would be enough to elect a President under the electoral college.
Is electoral college a viable component of American system of democracy?
This answer is subject to a wide range of opinion. The electoral college was a carefully thought compromise developed early in the nation's history. There were two main reasons for it: - Some of the founding fathers (Alexander Hamilton, for example) believed that the people were too naive and uninformed to choose good national leaders. A select team of educated people from each state could do the selection more wisely. - The electoral college allowed the smallest states a little bit of an extra voice in the choosing of the president. The electoral college remains an important part of American Republican Democracy. Candidates and parties vie for slight majorities in selected 'swing' states rather than fighting equally in all areas. The electoral college has several flaws: - The system can choose a president who has a minority of popular votes. In the 2000 election, Mr. Gore received 500,000 more votes than Mr. Bush, but lost. - The system provides a substantial bias in favor of the small states and against the largest states. - Because the smallest states are mainly aligned with one party and the largest two states with the other, the electoral college system favors one party over the other. - While the system is based upon the belief that the select people of the electoral college will use sound judgment, better than that of the common people, the present usage of the system actually removes the judgment from their hands. They are forced to vote with the party they are aligned with. So while the electoral college remains a viable component of the democracy, it should not be considered an essential or beneficial component.
What is a major flaw in the electoral collage system?
Some critics of the way the Electoral College performs its duty on using their votes to elect a US president has often come under fire. They believe that the national popular vote is the better way of doing this. They cite the current system flawed, but many others disagree.
What are some flaws of the Proportional Plan?
The Proportional Plan of electoral votes prevents a single candidate from receiving a states victory. The votes are distributed according to the percentage. This flaw is eliminated with a winner take all states.
