answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

If you are asking what judges use for guidance when they are making their decisions, there are several answers, and it will depend upon the proceeding and the type of judge and court.

First, all judges MUST follow/consider:

  • Relevant Statutes and Codes
  • Relevant Regulations; and
  • Binding Precedent (previous judicial opinions) that directly applies to the case at bar.
Whether a statute is "relevant" or a prior case is "binding" will depend upon the jurisdiction (where the court is) and what type of court it is (trial, intermediate appellate, or highest). Lower courts, for example, must follow the decisions of higher (appellate) courts in their jurisdiction that are directly relevant to their case.


However, it is not always clear whether a statute, regulation, or case is "relevant." This is because the meaning of the statute, code, or regulation can be ambiguous. Also, the "holding" of the prior cases (what rule it actually stands for), can be very unclear.


Accordingly, to interpret the meaning of a statute, judges will often look (for guidance) to:
  • The dictionary (to interpret the plain text of the statute),
  • Cannons of statutory construction (understood rules that judges follow when discerning the meaning of statutes -- for example, the "rule of lenity" provides that if a criminal statute is ambiguous, the judge should favor the defendant),
  • How other judges have interpreted the case, statute or regulation (even judges not in that jurisdiction),
  • The legislative history (reports of what the legislature was thinking when they enacted the statute),
  • Opinions of experts (to interpret technical or trade terms in the statute),
  • Unofficial administrative agency opinions (similar to experts), and
  • The circumstances in which the statute was written (to discern its purpose)
Again, judges may look for "guidance" to non-binding judicial opinions, they also look to "policy considerations," or what affect their opinion may have on the public at large.


In criminal cases, judges follow sentencing guidelines to give the appropriate sentence.


If the case is on appeal from an administrative decision or a lower court, judges may be required to give "deference" to the lower court's decision, and consider the lower court's reasoning in deciding the outcome of the case.


In short, judges seek guidance from several different sources. Attorneys play a large role in this as well by submitting briefs to the judge (often containing arguments similar to the ones given above), which the judge usually considers fully before making a decision.
User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

12y ago

A guiding principle for all judges is called: stare decisis. page 209

a) stare decisis

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago

stare decisis

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago

Rule of law

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: What is a guiding principle for all judges?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

What is guiding principle?

Guiding principles


What was the guiding principle for the laws in Hammurabis Code?

The guiding principle is that if you do something wrong you have punishment


What is the guiding principle that controls law enforcement in all they do?

Due Process


Which is the guiding principle of the constitution do you think is most important?

The principal that all people are created equal is the most important guiding principle of the United States Constitution. The Constitution guarantees the same rights for all American citizens.


Guiding principle for courts that makes decisions predictable and consistent?

Stare decisis is the guiding principle for courts that makes decisions predictable and consistent.


What is the guiding principles of geology?

The guiding principle of geology is uniformitarianism as established in the writings of Lyell.


What was Hitler's ethos?

His guiding principle was: 'I do what I can get away with'.


What is a five letter word for a crossword guiding principle?

tenet


Karyn does not borrow money out of a strong guiding rule?

Principle


What Form follows function is the guiding principle of what type furniture?

is form follow function the guiding principal to contempory furniture


What are the guiding principle of clean air act?

what is the Philippines air act 1999what is the primary good of philippines air act 1999what are the guiding principle of clean air act of 1999


What is a correct guiding of principle of composite risk management?

fluffiness easy as that