Want this question answered?
The Murmur of Replacement ceremony is a ceremony that shows that a child was too stupid to go somewhere and drown or die by ( accident )!
Roberto did not receive a replacement ceremony in "The Giver" because he failed in his training as a Nurturer and was released from the community instead. In the story, a replacement ceremony is only held when a citizen dies or is released from the community, but not specifically for those who fail in their assignments.
The Ceremony in "The Giver" occurred in the month of December.
The very last ceremony celebrated in the community in "The Giver" is the Ceremony of Release.
His name is not murmered because Release of an Elder is not the same as a loss, like Caleb.
They get new clothing
you get your bike
A haircut
Somebody dies and this is a ceremony to commemorate the persons life
The Ones receive their names and family at the Ceremony of the Ones.
They receive their first Bicycle.
she recieved a dream