Search unanswered questions...
Enter a question here...
Search: All sources Community Q&A Reference topics

Other contributors have said "What were the causes of the Civil War?" is the same question as "What were the causes of the US Civil War?". If you believe that these are not asking the same thing and should be answered differently, click here.


What were the causes of the US Civil War?

Answer

The secession of the South actually started the Civil War. The South wanted Slavery to be legal while the main percent of those living in the North did not.

Answer

The Civil War was not fought becuase of slavery. Slavery only became an issue after the Emancipation Proclamation, although some people in the North were pushing for war to stop slavery.

The was fought because the North did not think that the Southern states were allowed to seceed.



I fully agree with that, however, it can be argued that the war was fought because of slavery. Why did the southern states want to secede? Because they felt that they should have powerful states rights and a less powerful central govt that threatens slavery, and there for the southern economy and way of life. The Crittenden-Johnston Resolution stated that the war was being fought not to interfere with the southern way of life, but to keep the union together.

You could also include tariffs because, the south hated the tariffs because it hurt their economy but the North loved them because they protected their industries. Also Abraham Lincoln wasn't exactly liked by the south, given that he didn't even show up on the ballot in a couple states in the south.

Whoever wins the war, gets to write the history. So of course, the North did their best to think of an excuse for their onslaught on the South. The North was completely dependent on the South for their agriculture. Many Southerners didn't have slaves, in fact, Robert E. Lee didn't even own any. Lincoln claimed that any man would be convicted of treason. How is this so, when secession is a Constitutional right? When England and France found out about this, they were planning to come to the aid of the Southern states. If this had happened, no doubt the South would have won the War. To prevent this from happening, Lincoln had to think of some excuse-- slavery. This is when he decided to issue his Emancipation Proclamation, which freed the slaves in the Southern states. He had no right to do this, seeing as the states had already seceded, the slaves didn't belong to him. As it turned out, his Proclamation didn't free the slaves at all; it was not until the 13th Amendment that the slavery was abolished. Lincoln knew how important slaves were to maintain the South's agricultural industry, that's why he vowed in his 1861 inaugural address to protect the institution of slavery. Lincoln didn't even care about the slaves. When Union General Fremont freed the slave in the district he was commanding in Missouri, Lincoln fired Fremont, immediately re-enslaved the freedmen, and sent them back to their masters. So, why would he care if people had slaves, when as president, he was sending freed slaves back to their masters? When he imposed the Morrill Tariff on the Southern states, that was the last straw for them. Of course, the South didn't like him. He was neither fair nor just to the Southern states. As I said before, it is our Constitutional right to secede from the Union. It states this in the 10th Amendment of the Constitution. The South went to war to protect their rights. It had NOTHING to do with slavery. It was essential to the Union that the South remain with them, because of their benefits to the country. Then I could go on about how Lincoln destroyed the Constitution, made over 13,000 arbitrary arrests for people questioning as to why they were at war, shut down newspapers for questioning him, had the Chief Justice (Taney) of the Supreme Court thrown in jail for asking Lincoln was dismissing the fact that he had to get Congressional approval for the decisions he was making, BUT that's not anything to do with the cause of the war. Those are just a few more facts that go to what kind of person he really was.

The civil war started over the fact that the north didn't want to move slavery to the west. When the constitution was written it said that it was okay to have slavery where it was. Lincoln didn't think that slavery was okay, but he also didn't want to upset the south by telling them they could no longer have slavery. So he agreed they could keep slavery where it was when the constitution was signed. That was one of many reasons that the civil war started!

**I would like to say that the fact that people are saying the Civil War was started over slavery was wrong. The initial goal was to preserve the Union. Lincoln wanted the South to not further sucede more.The issue of slavery was later on the goal of the Civil War. Lincoln clarified that with the Emancipation Proclamation. The issue of slavery growing westward was always an issue,going back to the Kansas-Nebraska Act.The initial goal was to preserve the union at first.

Rebels of the North, How Land Policy Caused the Civil War is now available. It can be ordered through atlasbooks.com and will be available in book stores. New York History, a publication of the New York Historical Society requested a copy for review. Rebels of the North is the story of Robert Livingston and his 160,000 Manor. It describes his involvement with Captain Kidd and a 1686 lease to one of his farms. About 1750 the Boston Bay Colony laid out three townships that covered some of the land Livingston leased to farmers. The Boston Bay colony was giving 100 acres free to new settlers. The result was farmers refused to pay rent to Livingston. After the death of Steven Van Rensselaer the protest spread across most on New York State and formed a powerful political alliance that demanded a Homestead Act giving 160 acres of land free to new settlers. In the South the aristocrats were still in control and opposed a Homestead Act. They wanted the western land sold in blocks of 640 acres that could be worked by slaves. The nothern farmers moving west could not compete on that bases. After Buchanan vetoed the Homestead Act farmers switched parties and backed Lincoln who favored a Homestead Act. The south refused to back Douglas, who would allow slavery, and ran Breckenridge and Bell. The critical issue electing Lincoln was the Homestead Act and how the western land would be settled. Shay's Rebellion and the railroad grants are also discussed. The northern farmers grew wheat and hay and had livestock.

Basically, the South wanted to separate from the North. This was because the South didn't like some of the laws and such. One was about slavery, but they wanted slavery so they were mad.


Improve Answer View existing comments for "What were the causes of the US Civil War?" Click here to register and get updates when this answer is edited.

First answer by Imkrazie. Last edit by Scribble77. Contributor trust: 0 [recommend contributor]. Question popularity: 17 [recommend question]

Answers.com > Wiki Answers > Categories > History Politics and Society > History > War and Military History > US Civil War > What were the causes of the US Civil War?

Our contributors said this page should be displayed for the questions below. (Where do these come from)
If any of these are not a genuine rephrasing of the question, please help out and edit these alternates.
What led the civil war?  Wat caused the civil war?  What caused civil war US?  Why caused the civil war?  What led to the civil war?  What cuased the civil war?  Why did the civil war star?  WQhat caused the Civil War?  What started the silver war?  What led to the US civil war?  Whatwho caused the civil war?  What starteded the Civil War?  Why the civil was was fought?  One problem of the Civil War?  One problem led to civil war?  What Caused of the civil war?  Why was the civil war started?  One problem led the civil war?  What caused American Civil War?  Why did South and North fought?