Scotty McCreary
Chris Allen
Judges saves have not allowed a contestant to win and even judges choice did not allow any of the current contestants or past contestants to last that much longer.
American idol judges all season
Hailey Rienhart got voted off of American idol. 5/19/11
Carrie Underwood
Season 5
She was on American Juniors not idol, but she was one of the winners. I believe there were 5 of them.
Judges saves have not allowed a contestant to win and even judges choice did not allow any of the current contestants or past contestants to last that much longer.
Jacob Lusk was eliminated from American Idol 2011 Top 5.
American idol judges all season
Hailey Rienhart got voted off of American idol. 5/19/11
Carrie Underwood
Kellie Pickler did not win she was voted off in 6th place in season 5
On American Idol, He won in a competition. :)
Season 5
American Idol Extra - 2006 2-5 was released on: USA: 12 April 2007
American Idol Extra - 2006 1-5 was released on: USA: 13 April 2006
American Idol Extra - 2006 3-5 was released on: USA: 10 April 2008