0
It's been about two years since I read Chrétien's Grail romance, and I don't remember that particular detail, but I've got an explanation that I think is serviceable:
The identification of Arthur's sword is not something that was established; originally, it was called Caliburn, after all, and his spear and shield also had names. Chrétien, who was (probably) at least moderately familiar with the Welsh and the other British source material, may have just wanted to give Gawain's sword a name. He then (again, probably) checked his sources and found the name "Excalibur" for a sword - sounds good enough and he then took it.
Alternately, as Arthur's nephew and best knight, it may have been that Gawain had been loaned the sword for the mission at hand.
Wiki User
∙ 12y ago
In Chrétien de Troyes's Grail romance, Gawain wields Excalibur because he is portrayed as a prestigious and powerful knight, traditionally associated with King Arthur's court. The sword symbolizes Gawain's noble lineage and his prowess in battle, highlighting his heroic qualities in the story.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What is Sir Gawain?
For the Holy Grail . . .
What is sir Gawain quest?
For the Holy Grail . . .
Which of these items has NOT been sought by Indiana Jones the sword excalibur the sankara stones the holy grail or the ark of the covenant?
The sword excalibur
What has the author Karl Pietsch written?
Karl Pietsch has written: 'Spanish Grail fragments' -- subject(s): Grail, Lancelot (Prose romance), Merlin (Prose romance), Romances
What has the author Jessie Laidlay Weston written?
Jessie Laidlay Weston has written: 'Romance, vision & satire' -- subject(s): English poetry, Modernized versions 'Legend of Sir Lancelot Du Lac' 'Germanys literary debt to France' 'King Arthur and his knights' -- subject(s): Arthurian romances, History and criticism 'Sir Gawain and the Lady of Lys (Arthurian Romances \\' 'The legends of the Wagner drama' -- subject(s): Mythology, Germanic, Legends, Stories, plots, Stories of operas, German, Stories, plots, etc, Germanic Mythology 'Romance, Vision & Satire' 'Sir Gawain and the Green Knight: A Middle-English Arthurian Romance Retold in Modern Prose' 'Romance, Vision And Satire' 'Morien: A Metrical Romance' -- subject(s): Accessible book 'Arthurian Romances Unrepresented in Malory's \\' 'From ritual to romance' -- subject(s): Grail, History and criticism, Legends, Romances, Ritual, Knights and knighthood in literature, Graal (volkskunde), Quests (Expeditions) in literature, Medieval Literature, Arthurian romances, Riten, Legenden, Christendom 'Strapdown Inertial Navigation Technology (IEE Radar, Sonar, Navigation and Avionics, No 5) (Iee Radar, Sonar, Navigation and Avionics, No 5)' 'Sir Cleges' 'Old English carols from the Hill ms' 'Germany's literary debt to France' -- subject(s): German literature, History and criticism, Comparative Literature, German and French, French and German 'The legend of Sir Perceval' -- subject(s): Grail 'Sir Gawain and the Lady of Lys' -- subject(s): Arthurian romances, Gawain (Legendary character), Romances 'Sir Gawain and the Green Knight; A Middle-English Arthurian Romance Retold in Modern Prose' 'From Ritual to Romance' 'Legend of Sir Gawain Studies upon Its Original Scope and Significance' 'The legend of Sir Gawain' -- subject(s): Gawain (Legendary character), Sir Gawain and the Green Knight 'The quest of the Holy Grail' -- subject(s): Grail, History and criticism, Arthurian romances, Knights and knighthood in literature, Legends, Quests (Expeditions) in literature 'Sir Cleges AND Sir Libeaus Desconius (Arthurian Romances \\' 'The romance of Perlesvaus' -- subject(s): History and criticism, Arthurian romances, Knights and knighthood in literature, Legends, Grail, Perceval (Legendary character), Romances, Perlesvaus 'The Romance Of Morien' 'The Adventures Of Arthur At The Tarn Wadeling'
What are the 5 elements of a middle age romance?
A HeroA LadyA QuestA WastelandThe Grail
What does King Arthur send the knights on a search for?
In Chrétien de Troye's Perceval ou la Conte del Graal, the earliest extent graal romance, only Perceval and Gawain are shown to be searching for the grail. In this and most other romances the quest is primarily Perceval's personal quest. However increasingly the grail quest is seen is the central exploit of the Arthurian era. In the Prose Perceval which claims to be by Robert de Boron, when Perceval achieves the grail, that is the general end of wonderful adventures in Arthur's realm. Arthur subsequent conquest of Gaul which leads to a war with Rome is explained as an attempt to keep his knights interested by providing them with feats worthy of their valor.The prose romance Perlesvaus has Perceval, Gawain, and Lancelot all seeking the grail. And it is explained that Percveval's failure to ask the question when he first came to the grail castle has resulted in the illness of the grail king and general lethergy across all of Brtain. Even King Arthur has been affected. In the original Vulgate Arthur Cycle, consisting of the Prose Lancelot, The Quest of the Holy Grail, and The Death of Arthur, it is explained that Arthur's kingdom is afflicted with many difficult adventures, many of which are adventures of the grail. Only a promised best knight will achieve the most difficult of these adventures. Meanwhile the Knights of the Round Table do achieve many of the lesser adventures and put an end to the oppression they cause. Here first comes that idea that all Arthur's Knights of the Round Table take part in the quest of the grail.After the grail quest is achieved by Galahad, Perceval, and Bors there are no more wonderful adventures.
Who is holly grant?
The Holy Grail is a dish, plate, stone or cup that is part of an important theme of Arthurian literature. The grail, wondrous but not explicitly ñholyî first appeared in the ïPerceval le GalloisÍ an unfinished romance by Chretin de Troyes.
How is Hollie Grant?
Holy Grail can be described as a dish, plate, stone or cup that is part of an significant theme of Arthurian literature. The grail, wondrous but not explicitly ñholyî first appeared in the ïPerceval le GalloisÍ an unfinished romance by Chretin de Troyes.
Who retrieves the Holy Grail in knights of the round table?
That depends on who is telling the story. In the earliest versions of the story, it was Sir Perceval. Later romances made it Sir Galahad. At least one medieval German work has it be Sir Gawain.
What were some of the stories that surrounded the fantasy of King Arthur?
Some of the popular stories surrounding King Arthur include his conception by Uther Pendragon and Igraine, his pulling the sword Excalibur from the stone to prove his right to the throne, his marriage to Queen Guinevere, the formation of the Knights of the Round Table, his quest for the Holy Grail, and his eventual downfall at the hands of his son Mordred.
When was The Unholy Grail created?
The Unholy Grail was created in 1962.
