Search unanswered questions...
Enter a question here...
All Community Q&A Reference topics

Why were the Articles of Confederation weak?

[Edit]

Answer

my, etc

The articles gave the government no separation of powers. The government was too weak, the Articles left much of the power to the states (if I remember correctly, states basically went by their own state constitution). Congress didn't have the power to tax. To change the Articles, it had to be decided unanimously by all states. Also, 9 out of the 13 states had to approve any major law before it was passed and Congress couldn't regulate commerce. There was no president to lead, no established court system, and every state had only one vote in congress. Hope that helps!

Answer

The two biggest ones were the lack of taxing authority and the lack of an executive authority. Because it could not levy taxes the congress could not raise its own money for national purposes. It could only ask the states for money and they often refused to give it. Because there was no executive the congress could not enforce whatever laws it passed. The states could, and did, ignore them if they wanted to. With that kind of weakness it was very difficult to get anything done.
-Michael Montagne

Answer

There are many reasons as to why the Articles of Confederation are weak. In truth, the whole document was weak to begin with. The fact that the states had too much power, 9 out of 13 states had to approve laws, 13 out of 13 states had to approve amendments, and that Congress had no power at all, there was no ar. all had a factor in why the Ariticles of Confederation was weak.

Answer

  • central government was weakened by the Second Continental Congress = serious national and international problems
  • inability to regulate and levy taxes
  • states has more power and controled the gov't; did not gave the much needed money to debts from the cause of the war, basically ignored the congress
  • congress can't keep the states following the Treaty of Paris, many had their own foreign negotiations
  • a new nation was unable to defend its borders from British and Spanish encroachment because it could not pay for an army when the states would not contribute the necessary funds.

Improve Answer Discuss the question "Why were the Articles of Confederation weak?" Click here to register and get updates when this answer is edited.

First answer by Jeenius man. Last edit by 10486nichole. Contributor trust: 0 [recommend contributor]. Question popularity: 145 [recommend question]

Answers.com > Wiki Answers > Categories > History Politics and Society > History > United States History > Founding Fathers > Why were the Articles of Confederation weak?

Our contributors said this page should be displayed for the questions below. (Where do these come from)
If any of these are not a genuine rephrasing of the question, please help out and edit these alternates.
Why was the articles of confederation weak?  What are some shortcomings of the articles of confaderation?  Why were the articles weak?  How was the confederation weak?  Atricles of confederation weak?  What did the articles make weak?  Articles of confederation were weak?  Weak of the Article Of Confederation?  Why was artical of confederation weak?  Were the articles of conferation weak?  Why the articles of confederation weak?  Were the article of confederation weak?  Were the articles of confederation weak?  Facts about the articles of confederation?  Why were the articles of conferation weak?  Why is the articles of confederation weak?  Why was the articles of confedration weak?  Why was the article of confederation weak?  Why where th articles of condereation weak?  Why were the Articles of Confederaton weak?