Would a girl become interested if a guy sings a song to her on Valentine's Day?

Would A Girl Appreciate A Song Sung To Her On Valentine's Day?

• That's probably one of the sweetest things I've ever heard! I'd say go for it, because girls love that sort of thing.
  

• I think that sweet! Even if you couldn't carry a tune in a bucket I'd appreciate it! I'd have a bouquet of flowers handy though.

• I would love it if my husband sang to me on Valentine's Day. He says that he cannot carry a tune, but it wouldn't matter. I say go for it. It is a thoughtful gesture that most women would appreciate. Just a warning ... singing a song for that special girl would probably make her feel special, but you need to make sure you don't embarrass her. That means avoid doing it in front of lots of people. She may really like it, but there is the possibility she may not.

• That is the corniest thing I have ever heard of. I say NO! She will be embarrassed and you will never get her.

• That's so sweet! Yes, I agree with the public thing, you could take her on a picnic or something, where there's not too many people or do it at one of your own houses.

• I would totally dig a guys who did that even if they didn't sing well, but make sure it's not offensive in any way!

• If you're a good singer then yes, but if you embarrassed a girl in front of a lot of people the chances of her dating you are slimmer.

• She could become embarrassed because you knew that she liked you! No guy I've ever known would do that for a girl!

• Well depends on the situation; if it's the right time it would melt her heart. but if it is awkward, or whatever it will be a huge turnoff, and send her running! Literally! Just make sure the timing is right. If you sing to her, she will most likely think that it is really sweet, and she will love it whether she admits it or not. Go for it!

• That's so nice, but I agree with everyone else do not sing in public. She will most definitely like it, but don't overdo it as that would be too weird, but I really think you should go for it and having flowers is a good idea.

• Only if you've been dating for a long time, because if you sang her a song but you two have only been dating for a couple of months, that would make her feel really awkward. but, if you have been dating for a long time then that would be really sweet and she would remember that moment for a really long time, but don't just appear out of nowhere and start singing. Maybe write her a song and give it to her and say casually "would you like me to sing it to you?" or record your song and send it as a mix tape. You give her your heart without the awkwardness and embarrassment! Unless you feel really confidant and have extreme musical talent, go sing it, but if you're basically tone deaf, then stick to the advice and don't rap.

• I was simply going to say don't, but it's fair enough, after being together for a long time, this might be cute, and funny and cheesy, but lovely. This isn't something I would recommend on a first date. Awkward and over the top, make it fun if you ever do it, don't serenade someone after planning it for months, having lessons and everything and not telling them, it probably wouldn't be that great.

• Depends on the song and only do it if you know and are in the good books with her friends.

• Another more successful way you could do it is go out dancing at your special hang-out and when a romantic, slow song comes on softly sing the song in her ear and that way you don't risk embarrassing her. Most young woman would appreciate that more than being pin pointed in public or even with just the two of you alone.

• I guess it all depends if it's done in public, or if the guy singing is a GOOD singer. Even if he isn't, it can be comical if he doesn't take himself to seriously, but still be sentimental. I"m a chick that hates cliches more than anything, but I would absolutely melt if a guy sang a song for me. I think a guitar, piano, or musical instrument of some kind would help. Musicians are hot. Always have been since...forever.

• If you sang to a girl (especially on Valentine's Day) it would definitely make them more interested in you as long as you can sing reasonably well and its a song she likes, but you have to like it too. I would find it a big turn on; especially if it's accompanied with a piano or guitar.

First answer by Marcy. Last edit by Crisella. Contributor trust: 3 [recommend contributor]. Question popularity: 47 [recommend question]